Blessed Virgin Mary Church

Our Priests

Fr. Boyle was born into a military family living in New Jersey. Upon graduating from St. Joseph’s Academy in Richmond, MI he entered St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary, (then in Winona, Mn; now in Dillwyn, VA). After his ordination in June of 2009, he was appointed to Denver, CO. For six years he taught at the academy there and traveled to numerous chapels around the nation. In 2013, he was assigned as pastor and principal of the mission in St. Paul, MN.  In 2015, he was assigned as prior and principal at his Alma Mater in Michigan.  In 2017, Warners, NY welcomed Fr. Boyle as prior and prinicpal.

Fr. Steven Webber is a graduate of St. Mary’s Academy in Kansas and was ordained at St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary in Winona in 2002. His previous assignments have included being stationed in South Africa, England, and Canada. In 2025 he arrived in Warners, where he now serves as assistant pastor. 

Fr. Phillip DeLallo was born in California and raised in Kansas, where he received his early education at St. Mary's Academy. Transferring to Mater Dei for his final year of high school, he graduated with the MD Class of 2012 before entering St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary. He was ordained in 2021 and assigned to Warners, where he continues to serve his Alma Mater.

Father Gregory Pfeiffer was born and raised in Kentucky where he attended several small SSPX schools before graduating from Assumption Academy in Walton. He was ordained at St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary in 2023, after which he was assigned to Warners.

  • Assistant Priest
  • Chaplain of the Eucharistic Crusade
  • Pastor of St. Jude Roman Catholic Church, Eddystone, PA

Fr. Daniel Enriquez was born and raised in the Bay Area of Northern California and attended St. Thomas More School in San Jose. After completing his priestly training at St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary in Virginia, he was ordained in 2025 and came to Warners as his first assignment.

  • Assistant Priest
  • Directs altar servers for BVM Church and MDA

Br. Alphonsus grew up in Marietta, OH, where he attended Parkersburg Catholic High School and Marietta College. He made his final profession with the SSPX brothers in 2005, and has previously been stationed at St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary, La Salette Academy, and Our Lady of Sorrows Priory in Phoenix. He arrived in Warners in August of 2025.

  • Assistant Sacristan
  • Grounds and maintenance 

Br. Timothy was born and raised in the vicinity of Albany, New York. He graduated from La Salle Institute in Troy, NY, after which he went on to study anthropology at Warren Wilson College in Asheville, NC, and classical composition at the Aaron Copeland School of Music at Queens College in New York City. He spent a year as a house father at Mater Dei Academy before entering the brothers’ novitiate in Winona, where he made his first profession in 2024. He returned to Warners as his first assignment, where his current duties include cooking for the boarding school and priory as well as teaching high school and middle school boys.

  • Priory house cook